Fake
I think this one is still posted on fleabay. I saw it the day it posted. I was amazed how brazenly the seller called out the quality of the proofs. In my early days of collecting, I would send a message to the seller to point out the issues, but I got my head bit off a few times so I just leave it alone now.
Occasionally it goes the other way. I just bought off fleabay a matched 36 S/238. The auction page clearly stated that it was mismatched, but the pictures were just clear enough to show it was matched. It is rough, but worth the $80 I gave for it. If I can get the frog off it, I will sell it and reduce the price even farther.