Try to get some detailed pictures and post here. Not all refinished rifles are equal. If the metal was not buffed and the original markings are still sharp, that means a lot. I think this rifle is considerably more valuable than an RC. They are also rebelled and sanded, and totally mismatched. This rifle still has some historical value in that all parts are original to the rifle and show how duo was configuring them at this period in time. If truly all matching, i.e. not renumbered and the bore is excellent. It would make a great shooter that would probably appreciate in value. I think it would unquestionability bring a premium over an RC, the question is how much. I recently looked over a collection of about 50 RCs that were all available at $400. each, so that is my baseline. I would put a $150. premium on this rifle so say value of $550? I think on Gunbroker it would bring $600. Buyers there like pretty.
I completely understand that a seasoned collector would say this rifle, or an RC, has zero collector interest, but we must realize that the RC importations brought lots of new entry level collectors into the hobby, (a Good Thing) and they can't always afford, or have the comfort level to jump directly into a $2000. original matching example.
Again just my opinion and I respect thats others will differ.
This seller often makes mistakes on his description of K98s that his is trying to sell. He doesn't check all the numbers, over rates bore condition and over rates the blueing % in his descriptions from the dealing I have had with him. He also has a byf 45 for sale that he says is matching. After getting more pictures I informed him the rifle has issues. Wrong stock, wrong trigger guard and the stripper clip guide is ground off the back of the receiver. I think there was some more too but I forget now. He still doesn't mention all of the problems with the rifle in his add. So just be careful...
The byf has the wrong stock etc. Deleted the pictures long ago. The reason I brought that up is for you to ask for pictures and do a complete check on the rifle when you first get it to make sure it is what you wanted.
I was at my neighbors talking guns when he produced a model 98 German Mauser. He had found it in a cave in Vietnam in 1969 and bought it back. I know very little about rifles (more of a handgun guy), but being a history buff and knowing a little bit about German firearms I felt that I had a small piece of history in my hands.
My neighbor has had no interest in guns until recently and asked me to see if the the rifle could be restored to shooting condition. I'm posting here to obtain more information as to the history of the gun and if it is a good idea to restore it. I'm attaching photos of the gun and the markings. I've found that it is a 1944 build at the Waffenwerke Brunn in Bystrica Czhecoslovakia. It has matching serial #s (856) on the receiver and stock and 855 on the bolt. The front ring markings 3972 don't match and I can find no markings on the rear ring. Iv'e read that serial nos. from this factory for the period did not start this low so I don't know what to think.
The stock is in very poor structural condition (multiple cracks) but the receiver, barrel, bolt and other parts are ok except for some rust and pitting (bore looks great). It is missing the floorplate, mag spring, mag follower and set screws. Iv'e had no problem locating replacements. This, a new stock and a little work would make this a shooting rifle once more. Please feel free to share your thoughts on this.
The only argument against your logic is that russian captures are at bare minimum an official government refurb, while bubbas gunshop hot blue is just that. IMHO